This question just showed up:

Does Wifi signal strength affect link speed?

It's one of those borderline questions that at first glance make you want to vote to close. Then I thought, well, maybe it should be migrated to SuperUser (it's about Windows' interaction with wireless networking)...

But maybe it's more about general RF and antenna orientation, which might be better migrated to Physics. But I don't think Physics is quite as appropriate for radio spectrum questions when it clearly involves some sort of electronic circuit.

At the end of the day, I feel it's more about a consumer electronics application, not necessarily an EE challenge or problem.

Should it be addressed at all, or closed as off topic?

This question just showed up:

Does Wifi signal strength affect link speed?

It's one of those borderline questions that at first glance make you want to vote to close. Then I thought, well, maybe it should be migrated to SuperUser (it's about Windows' interaction with wireless networking)...

But maybe it's more about general RF and antenna orientation, which might be better migrated to Physics. But I don't think Physics is quite as appropriate for radio spectrum questions when it clearly involves some sort of electronic circuit.

At the end of the day, I feel it's more about a consumer electronics application, not necessarily an EE challenge or problem.

Should it be addressed at all, or closed as off topic?