I understand that asking questions about the choice of consumer electronics are not allowed, and with good reason. Similarly, opinion based questions otherwise too are not allowed. I would like to know whether questions asking about the best simulation software and/or practice, related to the design of electronics (such as a C-E amplifier), or electrical devices (such as a dc-dc converter- electric motor setup) allowed?

I am in conflict as to whether to ask them as they involve some opinion-related answers (as some them are commercial products), while on the other hand knowing and using simulation tools is a valuable skill for electrical engineers/hobbyists/students etc., and therefore knowing what the best tool is for the purpose beforehand goes a long way.

I have seen this question What is the correct SE channel to ask about an electrical engineering SOFTWARE question?; however that question was related to the usage of a certain software, which usually does not bring opinionated answers; while I ask about questions regarding the choice of software tools, which has the possibility of strongly opinionated answers


2 Answers 2


A opinion-based question might work in our EE.SE chat. The customs are more relaxed there.

"What software is best?" is such a common type of question that there is a separate stack for it: Software Recommendations SE. It was established for all kinds of software, rather than electrical engineering specifically.

Combined approach: post a question to Software Recommendations SE, then go to our EE.SE chat - or other SE chats where right kinds of expertise might hang out and post a link to the question there.


What you are proposing definitely sounds opinion-based, and therefore is not a good fit for this site. What software is best is pretty much always a bad question because so much of "best" depends on personal choices. And to make things worse, people often cling to their personal choices in a religious fashion. So not only do such questions end up being about opinions, they sometimes start holy wars.

Don't do it.


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .