4
Here are my thoughts:
I think it would be useful, however I don't know that it would be worth pursuing because it may not get enough site traffic or be able to pass through Area 51. One would have to build enough of a community to pass through these hurdles.
3
Echoing what Voltage Spike said, I don't think it would have enough traffic to survive as a standalone site. However, we do see design review questions here, and when asked with proper scope and detail, they seem to be generally acceptable.
2
I think we (the Royal We -- aka Stacks) aren't optimized to provide the back-and-forth discussions that need to take place for valuable design reviews for projects in our domain. We're just much better at specific questions. The task just seems better suited for a more forum-like environment.
Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible